They informed us there can be ups and downs. They informed us there can be rising pains. They informed us it will be well worth the wait — or that they’d not less than be affected person sufficient to seek out out it wasn’t.
However now, 18 months after drafting quarterback Anthony Richardson fourth general, the Indianapolis Colts are pulling the plug on the participant who was meant to place an finish to the QB merry-go-round that has plagued this franchise ever since Andrew Luck retired in 2019.
On Tuesday afternoon, information broke that the Colts (4-4) were officially making the move to bench Richardson in favor of 39-year-old backup Joe Flacco. Flacco will now begin for the Colts on Sunday night time towards the Minnesota Vikings (5-2).
GO DEEPER
Colts can’t improve until Shane Steichen, Anthony Richardson accept reality
It might have been comprehensible if Indianapolis ultimately determined Richardson was not part of its future. That’s not the end result anybody in Indianapolis wished, however the actuality is that not each extremely drafted QB pans out. Nonetheless, to do that simply 10 video games into Richardson’s profession is mind-bogglingly short-sighted.
The Colts determined to make this transfer following Richardson’s poor exhibiting Sunday, wherein he completed 10-of-32 passing in a 23-20 loss at Houston — take note Tyler Goodson dropped a landing; Will Mallory dropped a primary down; and Michael Pittman Jr., by his personal admission, didn’t do nearly enough to help Richardson as his high goal.
Colts coach Shane Steichen telegraphed Richardson’s benching Monday when he was requested if Richardson would stay the beginning QB in Week 9.
“We’re evaluating the whole lot,” Steichen stated
When pushed additional about Richardson’s starter standing, Steichen replied, “Proper now, in the present day, he’s, sure.”
However what about Sunday at Minnesota? “We’re evaluating,” he stated.
GO DEEPER
Colts noncommittal on Anthony Richardson as starting QB in Week 9
It didn’t take a genius to determine what was coming subsequent.
And let me be clear: Benching Richardson is a big mistake. To divorce themselves, even briefly, from the 22-year-old super-athlete who has barely performed half of a full NFL season, in favor of an nearly 40-year-old journeyman makes little sense.
Why?
Let’s begin with Richardson, whose confidence they’re killing and whose belief in Indy’s coaches and within the group goes to erode. Bear in mind, they didn’t simply promise Colts followers endurance. They promised him, too.
Clearly, he hasn’t performed the best way they’d hoped, however early struggles shouldn’t precisely have been a shock.
One of many largest issues about Richardson popping out of Florida was his lack of expertise. “He’s acquired blue traits, however there’s no résumé,” Colts assistant common supervisor Ed Dodds stated after the 2023 NFL Draft. 13 begins had been all Richardson had with the Gators, and he’s had even fewer within the NFL.
Richardson’s rookie yr being reduce to only 4 video games as a consequence of a season-ending shoulder damage wasn’t very best, nor was the indirect damage that knocked him out of two video games this yr. There are respectable issues about Richardson’s long-term sturdiness and whether or not he will be accessible sufficient to even be correctly evaluated.
However regardless of all of that, he’s at present wholesome, and the Colts wanted to play him as a lot as potential all through the remainder of this season, no matter how ugly it acquired, as a result of a season-long evaluation of Richardson is way more worthwhile than the choice.
GO DEEPER
Scoop City: Risers and fallers after Week 8
I can hear the refrain of Colts followers now: What about attempting to win now? What about making the playoffs? I’ll get again to these issues in a second, however for many who can’t wait, sure, Richardson’s improvement trumps all of that — particularly for the reason that best-case state of affairs with Flacco working the present doesn’t include a fairy-tale ending.
Look, there’s no sugarcoating Richardson’s struggles. He hasn’t performed just like the promising QB he regarded like final yr when he scored seven complete touchdowns in simply 4 video games. However a giant a part of Richardson’s regression this yr, I imagine, has been Steichen’s play calling, which appears to be much less tailor-made to Richardson’s strengths than it was final season. I requested Steichen, who after each recreation says he’s “gotta be higher,” how he will be higher as a play caller for his younger QB.
“Working the ball higher, placing him in less complicated positions, getting the ball out of his arms faster so he’s not dropping again, sitting again there,” Steichen stated Monday.
So, why hasn’t Steichen accomplished extra of that? In any case, that is “his man,” in accordance with proprietor Jim Irsay, who leaned on Steichen’s opinion when evaluating quarterbacks forward of the 2023 NFL Draft. Richardson wouldn’t be in Indianapolis if Steichen hadn’t advocated for it.
Hold that in thoughts as you think about this benching. And this, too: Pulling the plug on Richardson is a transparent indictment of Steichen, who both did not develop Richardson correctly or failed in his analysis of the QB.
I lean towards the previous, as we’re eight video games into Richardson’s second season, and for the six Richardson has performed, he’s been requested far too many instances to be a pure pocket passer when everyone knows accuracy is his largest on-field difficulty.
Within the season opener this yr, Richardson seemed to be choosing up the place he left off after a promising rookie marketing campaign. His 60-yard landing go to Alec Pierce captivated the NFL world. However since then, the curler coaster has been much more down than up.
Richardson has thrown 4 touchdowns towards seven interceptions this season. His 44.4 completion share is the worst within the NFL amongst certified QBs. And he didn’t garner any grace by subbing himself out Sunday as a result of he was “drained” following a failed scramble towards the Texans wherein, in equity to Richardson, he chucked a 318-pound defensive sort out off his again.
“We had a dialog about it, and I believe he is aware of that’s not the usual that he must play as much as and the remainder of the crew holds him to,” stated middle Ryan Kelly, the Colts’ longest-tenured participant. “I’ll form of depart the dialog we had at that, however I’m certain he’s gonna take some criticism for that and rightfully so. That’s a troublesome look. … But when anybody ever questions how arduous he performs, I don’t assume that that’s the case.”
Steichen stated Monday that Richardson’s request to be subbed out for one play didn’t issue into the crew’s choice to reevaluate who would be the beginning QB at Minnesota. Nevertheless it clearly didn’t go over properly within the locker room, and it’s honest to counsel that Richardson could need to rebuild his repute a bit amongst his friends, all of whom have continued to assist him publicly.
However regardless of the unhealthy optics for Richardson, benching him is a horrible overreaction by the Colts.
Certain, a sound argument will be made that Flacco has been steadier and doubtless even higher than Richardson this season. The previous Tremendous Bowl MVP has thrown seven touchdowns towards one interception whereas going 1-1 as Richardson’s backup. However keep in mind what I stated concerning the best-case state of affairs? It’s not as rosy as some might imagine. Even when Flacco performs properly and leads Indianapolis to the playoffs, this isn’t a crew with a sensible probability of profitable the Tremendous Bowl.
These Colts aren’t beating the Chiefs within the playoffs. Or the Bills. Or the Ravens.
Indy’s protection has been injured and inconsistent. Its high vast receiver, Pittman, has a foul again. And its beginning left sort out, Bernhard Raimann, simply entered concussion protocol days earlier than Indianapolis has to face an all the time difficult Brian Flores-led protection in Minnesota.
Does that sound like a recipe for fast success or future development? To me, it feels like a surefire path to mediocrity. And the Colts are embracing it. Even when they handle to complete 9-8 or 10-7 whereas clinching their first playoff berth since 2020, they’d be sacrificing their draft positioning subsequent spring and beginning over once more at quarterback with a worse choose than if Richardson merely performed and struggled.
Maybe others could possibly be satisfied that Richardson’s benching is just momentary, and that his time on the sideline this season will assist him be taught and put together for a redo in 2025. Possibly, however the Colts at the moment are working the chance of shattering Richardson’s confidence. At this level, by the point he performs once more, it will likely be his third NFL season, and the crew will nonetheless be no nearer than it’s now to understanding if it has its long-term reply at quarterback.
They’re simply kicking the can down the highway.
“I positively might have delivered the ball higher. I positively might have made some higher checks. I might have performed higher. I positively perceive that,” Richardson stated after Sunday’s loss. “Even after we play properly and we win the sport, they’re going to say, ‘A.R. was the primary purpose we gained.’ You’ve simply acquired to have the ability to take each side of it, the wins and the losses.
“I’m simply steadily attempting to develop and simply maintain getting higher.”
That’s not going to occur now as Colts chase one other early playoff exit as a substitute of seizing each alternative for his or her younger QB to sink or swim.
“Peyton (Manning’s rookie) yr we had been 3-13 the primary yr, and that’s a man who performed a number of faculty video games and was actually ready as a lot as he could possibly be for the league,” Irsay stated on “The Pat McAfee Present” in July 2023. “So, for Anthony Richardson it’s gonna be robust. We all know that. However he has to play to get higher. There’s no query.”
So, why are they questioning it now?
(Photograph: Stacy Revere / Getty Pictures)